Updated

PL

Analysis

A doctor in a public hospital and in a private practice — how other countries regulate it.

Canada makes the doctor choose one side, Spain requires permission and publishes it, Italy reports to parliament every year. In Poland the law requires neither permission nor notification — and nobody knows how many doctors combine the two sectors.

Written by
Editors
Reading time
8 min

A doctor who works in a public hospital in the morning and sees patients privately in the afternoon breaks no rule in Poland. The trouble starts where both workplaces meet the same patient: the queue in one is shortened in the other, and where the patient ends up is decided by a person who earns on both sides. We checked how fifteen countries regulate this situation, whether the state knows how many doctors it concerns, and what part of it is public.

Four approaches

The countries we describe use one of four models — from separating the sectors to having no rules.

Doctors working in the public and private sector at the same time — rules and transparency
RuleDoes the state know the scaleWhat is public
PolandNo permission and no notification; a non-compete ban only by agreementNoNothing
CanadaThe doctor chooses: the public plan or practice outside itYes — the number of doctors outside the plan in most provincesFigures in the annual federal report
SpainPermission from the authority, entry in a register; working without permission is a very serious offenceIt knows the permissions, not the hoursPermissions — in Madrid by name
HungaryPrior permission from a designated body; working without applying may lead to dismissalWe found no data on the number of permissionsNothing
ItalyThe doctor chooses exclusivity or practice outside the hospital; with exclusivity the doctor may see private patients in the hospitalYes — an annual report to parliamentThe number of doctors and total revenue
FrancePrivate practice in a public hospital for up to 20% of working time, under a contractYes — the number of doctors and their fees in the sickness fund’s dataAggregate figures
United KingdomA duty to disclose to the employer; permission is not neededThe employer knowsPrivate consultants’ prices — by name
GermanyWritten notification in advance; the employer may prohibitWe found no dataNothing
DenmarkA duty to inform the employer — for senior doctors and managersAudit of 2016: two of three regions did not enforce itNothing
SwedenAllowed unless it undermines trust; otherwise the employer must prohibit itThe region examined carried out no checksNothing
CzechiaThe employer’s consent only for activity that coincides with the employer’s ownWe found no dataNothing
AustriaRules in the law of the federal states — we did not establish themWe found no dataNothing
BelgiumWe did not establish thisWe found no dataNothing
The NetherlandsWe did not establish thisWe found no dataNothing
USAA ban on referring patients of the public programme to the doctor’s own entitiesNot applicableNot applicable

Choosing one side: Canada

Canada separates the sectors most sharply. A doctor participating in a province’s public plan bills only the plan and may not charge the patient extra. The doctor can opt out of the plan — but then the plan does not pay for the doctor’s services, or reimburses the patient at most the rate from the fee schedule. Outside Quebec only a handful do so: in 2024–25 Ontario had 37,442 doctors in the plan and 10 outside it, and British Columbia 13,385 and 24. The figures are given every year in a federal report; Quebec did not submit its own.1

Quebec, where there are more doctors outside the plan, restricted departures by an act in April 2025: according to the provincial government’s announcement, new doctors are to work in the public network for five years, and moving to the private sector requires the consent of a public agency.2

Permission and exclusivity: Spain, Hungary, Italy, France

Spain requires permission. An act of 1984 requires permissions to be entered in the personnel register and bans private activity connected with the doctor’s own unit, and working without permission is a very serious disciplinary offence.3 4 The transparency act requires such permissions to be published, and Madrid does so by name — with the doctor’s name, position and hospital.5 6

Hungary introduced permission in 2021. A doctor employed in a state or local-government hospital may take up additional gainful work only with the prior permission of a designated body, which has eight days to decide; working without applying may lead to dismissal with immediate effect. Within the public post, a doctor also may not treat a patient whom the doctor previously treated for the same illness outside that post.7 8 We found no figure for the number of permissions granted.

Italy gives a doctor of the public health service a choice: exclusivity with a pay supplement, or practice outside the hospital. A doctor with exclusivity may see private patients in their own hospital, after hours, and the hospital takes part of the fee. The health minister submits a report to parliament every year: in 2023, 37.9% of employed doctors used this option, and revenue amounted to €1,286.1 million, of which €1,000.0 million went to staff.9 The report gives the total amount, not the earnings of individual doctors.

France allows doctors employed in a public hospital to practise privately in the same hospital on three conditions: the doctor performs the same kind of work as part of the public service, the private practice takes up no more than 20% of working time, and the number of private consultations and procedures is lower than the number of public ones. France’s audit office (Cour des comptes) found in 2023 that these restrictions are easy to circumvent — because of insufficient oversight and tolerance of frequent abuses.10 The same three conditions still apply.11 In 2022, 4,671 doctors had a private practice in a public hospital, and their fees amounted to €644 million.11

Notification: the United Kingdom, Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Czechia

In this group the doctor has a duty to inform the employer, and the employer may object.

In the United Kingdom a consultant must disclose commitments to private patients to the employer, but does not need permission.12 13 Separately, the competition authority ordered in 2014 that consultants in private practice submit their prices for consultations and procedures to an independent organisation, which publishes them.14

In Germany the collective agreement for municipal hospitals requires written notification of a paid occupation in advance; the employer may prohibit it or impose conditions.15 A doctor contracted by the sickness funds, in turn, may not take on additional work to an extent that prevents them from seeing the funds’ patients.16

In Denmark the duty to inform arises from a collective agreement and applies to chief physicians, senior doctors and ward doctors. The national audit office established in 2016 that two of the three regions examined did not enforce it, and that nearly half of the senior doctors heading departments had secondary occupations despite a ban in force in two regions.17

In Sweden the act bans a public employee from occupations that may undermine trust in their impartiality, and the employer has a duty to prohibit such an occupation.18 In 2023 the auditors of the Västerbotten region checked the company register: 378 of the region’s 1,547 doctors held a position or shares in a company. In a sample of 60 such cases, 13% had been notified and documented.19 The register shows shareholdings and board positions, not private practice itself, and concerns one region.

In Czechia the labour code requires the employer’s written consent only for gainful activity that coincides with the employer’s line of business.20

No statutory rules: Poland

In Poland the act on medical activity and the act on the professions of doctor and dentist do not require a doctor to obtain the employer’s permission for, or to notify the employer of, work in another place.21 22 The exception is the head of a public facility, who needs the written consent of the founding body for any other employment.21 The labour code goes in the opposite direction: an employer may not prohibit an employee from working in parallel, unless they have concluded a separate non-compete agreement.23 Doctors working on civil-law (B2B) contracts are not covered by the labour code.

Nobody measures the scale. The only data come from a 2026 survey by the medical chamber, carried out on a sample that is not random: 30.8% of respondents worked only in the public sector, 11.9% only in the private sector, and 54.9% combined the two. Among the problems of such combining, doctors pointed to adding patients out of turn (41.4%) and the use of public resources (35.4%).24 Since August 2026 the health minister has been able to demand from facilities data on the pay and working time of specific persons, but only on request and without publication.25

A different divide: the USA, Austria, the Netherlands, Belgium

In the USA the same doctor sees patients of public programmes and of private insurers, so the question of combining sectors makes no sense there. What is regulated instead is the conflict of interest: an act bans a doctor from referring patients of the Medicare programme to an entity with which the doctor has a financial relationship. The federal audit office established on 2010 data that doctors referring to their own diagnostic facilities ordered about twice as many MRI and CT scans as the others.26 27

In Austria, alongside doctors with a sickness fund contract there are practices without one: the patient pays in full and gets part of the cost reimbursed by the fund. In 2023 patients submitted bills for €551.45 million to the largest fund, of which the fund reimbursed €208.85 million.28 We did not establish how many hospital doctors run such practices.

For the Netherlands and Belgium we found neither rules nor data on how many hospital doctors work in parallel in competing clinics.

What follows from this

It can be known

examples from the countries described

  • How many doctors are in the public system and how many outside it — Canada, every year.
  • Which doctor has permission for private work — Madrid, by name.
  • How many public doctors see patients privately and what revenue this brings — Italy and France, in aggregate.

Nobody shows

in any of the countries described

  • How much a doctor earns in total on both sides.
  • How many hours the doctor works in each sector.
  • How many patients moved from the doctor’s private practice to the public ward.

The countries described do not ban doctors from private work as such — Canada goes furthest, making them choose one side. They differ in whether anyone knows about that work. Where permission or a choice of one side is required, a register comes into being, and statistics can be made from a register. Where notifying the employer is enough, audits in Denmark and Sweden showed that the notifications are often simply not there.

Poland is among the countries with neither permission, nor notification, nor statistics. This site’s demand — total pay from public money under a permanent identifier instead of a name — does not concern private earnings. It would, however, show how much work a doctor does at the public payer’s expense, and that is the first figure needed for a discussion about combining the two sectors. We describe the mechanism in the texts on working in many places and on the queue and the price of a private visit.

Method

For every country we checked four things: what rule follows from an act or a collective agreement, whether the state or the payer knows the scale of the phenomenon, what is published and what audit bodies have established. We rely on the texts of acts, the reports of audit offices and public authorities, and reports to parliaments. Where we write “we found no data”, we are not claiming that none exist — we did not manage to reach an official source. We describe the countries at greater length in the texts collected on the page Healthcare in other countries.

The assessment of oversight in France comes from a report of 2023; the conditions themselves are confirmed by a report of 2025. The data on Denmark come from an audit of 2016.

Notes 28laws, data and statements we relied on
  1. Health Canada, Canada Health Act Annual Report 2024–2025. ↩

  2. Government of Quebec, announcement of the adoption of Bill 83 (in French), 24 April 2025. ↩

  3. Act 53/1984 on incompatibilities of the personnel of public administrations (in Spanish), Articles 11, 14 and 18. ↩

  4. Act 55/2003 on the framework statute of health service personnel (in Spanish), Articles 72 and 73. ↩

  5. Act 19/2013 on transparency, access to public information and good governance (in Spanish), Article 8(1)(g). ↩

  6. Community of Madrid, decision of 27 October 2023 on access to information (in Spanish). ↩

  7. Act C of 2020 on the healthcare service relationship (in Hungarian), Article 4. ↩

  8. Government decree 528/2020 (in Hungarian), § 6–7. ↩

  9. Italian Minister of Health, report to parliament on doctors’ private practice in public facilities for 2023 (in Italian; Chamber of Deputies, Doc. CLXVIII no. 3, transmitted on 8 July 2025), table 3. ↩

  10. Cour des comptes, Les établissements de santé publics et privés, entre concurrence et complémentarité (in French), 12 October 2023, pp. 64–66; earlier to the same effect in the report Les personnels des établissements publics de santé (in French), 2006, pp. 52–53. ↩

  11. Haut Conseil pour l’avenir de l’assurance maladie, report on extra billing, annex 2 (pp. 28–29: the conditions in force; table 3: doctors and fees) (in French), October 2025. ↩ ↩2

  12. NHS Employers, Terms and Conditions – Consultants (England) 2003, version of 16 May 2025, schedule 9: paragraphs 3–4 (the consultant informs the clinical manager of regular private practice, at least once a year at the job plan review), paragraph 12 (the employer’s agreement is needed only for the use of NHS resources). ↩

  13. British Medical Association, Consultants and private practice — a page of the doctors’ trade union. ↩

  14. Competition and Markets Authority, Private Healthcare Market Investigation Order 2014, Articles 20–22. ↩

  15. Collective agreement for doctors at municipal hospitals (TV-Ärzte/VKA) (in German), § 3(3), as of July 2025. ↩

  16. Zulassungsverordnung für Vertragsärzte (in German), § 20. ↩

  17. Rigsrevisionen, the health minister’s response concerning report no. 3/2016 on hospital doctors’ secondary occupations (in Danish), 17 March 2017. ↩

  18. Lag (1994:260) om offentlig anställning (in Swedish), § 7–7c. ↩

  19. Revisorerna Region Västerbotten, Kontroll över bisysslor, report 6/2023 (in Swedish), December 2023. ↩

  20. Labour code (act 262/2006) (in Czech), § 304. ↩

  21. Act on medical activity, consolidated text (in Polish; Journal of Laws 2026, item 156); consent for the head of a facility: Article 47(3). ↩ ↩2

  22. Act on the professions of doctor and dentist, consolidated text (in Polish; Journal of Laws 2026, item 37). ↩

  23. Labour code, consolidated text (in Polish; Journal of Laws 2025, item 277), Articles 26¹ and 101¹. ↩

  24. Supreme Medical Chamber, Centre for Research and Analysis, report on the “Perspektywa 27” survey (in Polish), 2026 — an online survey, 29 April–4 May 2026, N = 2243. ↩

  25. Act of 19 June 2026 amending the act on healthcare services financed from public funds and the act on medical activity (in Polish; Journal of Laws 2026, item 972). ↩

  26. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Physician Self-Referral. ↩

  27. US Government Accountability Office, Medicare: Higher Use of Advanced Imaging Services by Providers Who Self-Refer Costing Medicare Millions, GAO-12-966, 2012. ↩

  28. Rechnungshof, Ärztliche Versorgung im niedergelassenen Bereich 2018 bis 2023 — press release (in German), 12 December 2025. ↩

Change history 1

latest change 19 November 2026 · Update to more recent sources: Italy according to the report for 2023 (37.9% of doctors, €1,286.1 million in revenue), the assessment of oversight in France according to the audit office’s report of 2023 instead of 2006.
  1. Update to more recent sources: Italy according to the report for 2023 (37.9% of doctors, €1,286.1 million in revenue), the assessment of oversight in France according to the audit office’s report of 2023 instead of 2006.

How this text was made. The sources are public documents, data and legal acts — each linked in the notes. AI tools help process them: organise, calculate and edit the text. The editors decide on the arguments and approve every publication.

Spotted an error? We publish corrections in a register, with the date and a description of each change. We describe mechanisms, not individuals.

Report a correction

Editorial position

Public amounts, protected names.

We call on the state to publish, every quarter, the total pay of each person working in facilities with a National Health Fund (NFZ) contract — summed across all their workplaces, under a permanent identifier instead of a name.

Popular