Updated

PL

Mechanisms

No-fault: compensation without blame and a doctor’s liability.

The word no-fault covers three different arrangements. Abroad it means paying a patient without naming who was at fault. In Poland the medical self-government also uses it for removing criminal liability for an unintentional error.

Published
Written by
Editors
Reading time
9 min

A patient harmed in a Polish hospital can take four routes today: apply to the Compensation Fund, sue the hospital, notify the prosecutor’s office, or complain to the disciplinary prosecutor at a medical chamber. The label no-fault appears in disputes about each of these routes, but each time it means something else.

Below: what the word means, how such systems work in countries that have had them for decades, what has been passed and what is proposed in Poland — and what would remain of a doctor’s liability if criminal liability for an unintentional error were removed.

Three meanings of one word

In healthcare, no-fault names three separate arrangements. Each can be introduced without the others.

In Poland only the first of the three arrangements is in force, and the dispute is about the second

What it meansStatus in Poland
Compensation without deciding on faultthe patient is paid from a fund or an insurer and does not have to show who was at faultin force since 6 September 2023: the Medical Events Compensation Fund, only for harm suffered in a hospital
Limited criminal liabilitythis is what the dispute is aboutfor an unintentional error in treatment, staff are not criminally liable or are treated more lenientlythis is what the dispute is aboutnot in force; a demand of the medical self-government under the name “clause of the higher good”
Protection for the reportera person who reports an error to an adverse-event register bears no consequences for that reportit was in the government bill of 2022; the quality act that was passed does not contain it
Source: Act of 16 June 2023 amending the Act on patient rights (Compensation Fund), in PolishSource: Government bill on quality in healthcare, Sejm paper no. 2898, in Polish

Abroad, no-fault usually means the first arrangement, sometimes together with the third. In the Polish debate the medical self-government uses the word mainly for the second.

How it works in other countries

The oldest systems are those of the Nordic countries and New Zealand. They share one thing: the patient applies to a body that assesses the harm, not the person. They differ in when they pay.

“No-fault” does not mean “for every harm”: in Denmark and Norway fewer than one in four applicants receives compensation

When the patient is paidHow many applications end in paymentScale
Swedenwhen the harm could have been avoided had an experienced specialist provided the carejust over 40% of cases decided in 202522,800 reports, just under 740 million kronor paid out in 2025
Denmarkwhen an experienced specialist would have acted differently, and also for rare and serious complications even though everyone acted correctly22.3% of decisions in 202413,327 reports, 838.53 million kroner paid out in 2024
Norwaywhen the provision of care failed, “even if no one can be blamed”24% in 2025 (30% in 2020)8,382 applications, 1,063 million kroner paid out in 2025; 225 days to a decision on average
New Zealandwhen the injury results from treatment; neither fault nor negligence has to be provenabout 37% of claims are declinedthe scheme covers all injuries; ordinary damages cannot be sought in court
Each country counts its percentages differently (of decisions, of applications), so they show an order of magnitude, not a ranking.Source: Löf, Skadestatistik 2025 (in Swedish)Source: Patienterstatningen, Årstal 2024 (in Danish)Source: Norsk pasientskadeerstatning, Årsrapport 2025 (in Norwegian)Source: Andrew, Journal of Hospital Management and Health Policy, 2025

The Swedish insurer Löf, owned by the regions, describes the rule as follows: compensation is due if the harm could have been avoided with care provided by an experienced specialist, and not merely because the treatment did not bring the expected result.1 Denmark applies a similar test and in addition pays for rare and serious complications even when no one made an error.2 The Norwegian act grants compensation when the harm results from a failure in the provision of care, “even if no one can be blamed”.3

These bodies do not link the number of applications to the number of errors. The Norwegian fund recorded a record 8,382 applications in 2025 and noted that it has no reason to believe treatment errors are increasing.4

In New Zealand the scheme replaced civil litigation: an injured person cannot sue for ordinary damages and is left only with a rarely used claim for exemplary damages. The author of a 2025 review reports that about 37% of treatment injury claims are declined.5

These systems are criticised in their own countries. The French fund ONIAM, which since 2002 has paid for serious medical accidents without fault, was assessed in 2017 by the French Court of Audit: it found the results “very far from the objectives”, the commissions had rejected three quarters of applications because of the severity threshold, and proceedings involving the fund took 2 years and 9 months on average.6

What remains of liability in those countries

In none of the countries described did the payment system replace the liability of the individual. Two tracks remained: criminal law and supervision of the profession.

The criminal track. In Sweden a doctor or nurse can be held liable for causing bodily harm or the death of a patient. Charges are rare, but they do occur and have ended in convictions, writes a Swedish scholar of medical law.7 In the United Kingdom, which did not introduce no-fault, 47 healthcare professionals, including 37 doctors, were prosecuted for gross negligence manslaughter between 1994 and 2018; 23 were convicted and 4 convictions were overturned on appeal.8

Supervision of the profession. In Sweden and Norway state bodies decide on the right to practise; in Denmark complaints about staff are handled by a state disciplinary board, independent of those who run healthcare.9 In New Zealand complaints go to the independent Health and Disability Commissioner, who received 3,477 of them in 2024/25.10

This supervision is used. In 2020–2025, authorities in Norway and Sweden revoked the right to practise about 90 times more often than Polish medical courts per number of doctors, and the British tribunal about 16 times more often. The systems differ in the range of cases, so this is an order of magnitude, not an exact measure; the calculation and caveats are in the analysis The harshest penalty that is almost never imposed.

Poland: commissions, the quality act, the Fund

Voivodeship commissions. From 2012, voivodeship commissions ruled on whether a medical event had occurred. The Supreme Audit Office (NIK) examined eight of them and concluded in 2018 that proceedings before a commission “did not become a real alternative to court proceedings”. Applicants rejected 71.9% of the compensation offers made by hospitals, and the average length of first-instance proceedings ranged, depending on the commission, from 4 to 10.2 months.11 The commissions were abolished in 2024.12

The quality act. The government bill of December 2022 contained two no-fault elements. It prohibited reprisals against a person who reported an adverse event. It also allowed a court to apply extraordinary mitigation of the penalty to a doctor, nurse, midwife, paramedic or laboratory diagnostician for unintentionally exposing a patient to danger or unintentionally causing bodily harm — provided the perpetrator reported the event before law enforcement learned of it, was not under the influence of alcohol and did not breach the rules of caution intentionally or grossly.13 That act fell: the Senate rejected it, and on 14 April 2023 the Sejm failed to gather the majority needed to override the Senate’s resolution.14 The act passed in June 2023, based on a bill tabled by deputies, contains no provisions on mitigating the penalty or on prohibiting reprisals against the reporter.15

The Medical Events Compensation Fund. It has operated at the Patient Ombudsman since 6 September 2023 and is the Polish version of the first meaning of no-fault. It pays when an infection, bodily harm or the death of a patient “could with high probability have been avoided”, and only when the harm occurred in a hospital during services financed from public funds. The act sets amounts from PLN 2,000 (≈ €449) to PLN 200,000 (≈ €44,900) for a patient and from PLN 20,000 (≈ €4,490) to PLN 100,000 (≈ €22,400) for a relative after the patient’s death, indexed every year.16

In 2025 the Fund received 2,577 applications. The Ombudsman issued 586 decisions granting a payment and 707 refusals. He paid out PLN 34.3 million (≈ €7.7 million), on average PLN 58,000 (≈ €13,000).17 How to apply is described in the guide Patient rights.

Three features of the Fund matter for liability:

  1. 01.

    It does not establish who was at fault. The Ombudsman’s report states plainly: “Obtaining a payment does not require proving the fault of the healthcare provider”. The act does not provide for passing a case to a disciplinary prosecutor or a public prosecutor.

  2. 02.

    It closes the civil route. Accepting the payment amounts to waiving claims for damages, an annuity and compensation for harm that became apparent by the day the application was filed.

  3. 03.

    The conclusions stay in the hospital. After a payment the hospital must analyse the causes of the event and implement recommendations. The act does not require it to present that analysis to anyone.

Applications are assessed by a team in which at least 15 of at least 20 members must be doctors.16

What the medical self-government wants

In February 2024 the presidia of the Supreme Medical Council and the Supreme Council of Nurses and Midwives adopted a joint position: “The risk of criminal liability for unintentional acts resulting from the provision of health services should be lifted from persons practising medical professions. The patient, in turn, should be given mechanisms allowing effective, quick and out-of-court compensation for the harm suffered”.18 The self-government calls this demand the clause of the higher good.

A defendant’s chair on which, instead of a person, lies a stack of ring binders with a judge’s gavel on top; a doctor’s coat hangs in the background

The position concerns criminal liability; it does not mention civil or professional liability. According to the legal news service Prawo.pl, the proposal of the medical community is to add a provision to the Criminal Code: a person practising a medical profession would not be liable for an unintentional offence unless they were under the influence of alcohol or intoxicants, or the result stemmed from a gross failure to exercise caution.19 The self-government has not published the full wording of the provision in the documents we reached.

A similar provision has already been in force. The act of 28 October 2020 excluded the criminality of unintentional acts committed when diagnosing and treating COVID-19 during the state of epidemic, “unless the result caused was the outcome of a gross failure to exercise the caution required in the circumstances”.20

On 2 June 2025 the minister of health appointed a team which a month later was named the Team for Legal Solutions on the Civil and Criminal Liability of Doctors and Dentists. It is to draw up a concept of provisions “serving to strengthen patient safety” and to reduce adverse events. The order sets no deadline and binds the members to confidentiality.21 By 17 November 2026 we had found no published report of the team and no bill with such a clause.

What remains when criminal liability is gone

Today a doctor who made an error can be assessed by three institutions independent of one another. The clause changes one of them.

With criminal liability removed, the only institution that assesses the doctor as a person is the court of the doctor’s own self-government

Who assessesWhom it assessesAfter the clause is introduced
Criminal routethis is what the clause changesprosecutor and common courtthis is what the clause changesa personthis is what the clause changesonly a gross failure to exercise caution, alcohol and intoxicants
Compensation FundPatient Ombudsmanthe event, not a personno change
Civil lawsuitcommon courtmost often the hospital and its insurerno change; closed to those who accepted a payment from the Fund
Professional liabilitydisciplinary prosecutor and medical court at a medical chambera personno change
Source: Act on the Compensation Fund, Articles 67q–67zi (in Polish)Source: Act on medical chambers (in Polish)

In 2020–2025, medical courts imposed 2,516 penalties at first instance. 86% of them were an admonition, a reprimand or a fine. In 2010–2025, 20 doctors finally lost the right to practise.22 Doctors are judged there by doctors elected by assemblies of doctors, and a case leaves the self-government only with a cassation appeal to the Supreme Court — as described in How Poland’s medical courts work.

A civil lawsuit concerns the facility, not the person. The Ministry of Justice keeps records of cases for damages “for harm caused by the health service” and divides them by defendant: a public healthcare facility, the State Treasury or local government, a non-public facility. In 2024, 685 such cases were filed with district and regional courts. First-instance courts disposed of 643: in 184 (29%) they upheld the claim in whole or in part, they dismissed 169, and 16 ended in a settlement. At the end of the year 2,302 cases were pending — more than three times as many as the courts disposed of during the year.23

Four weak points of the Polish version of no-fault follow from this comparison:

  1. 01.

    The track independent of the profession disappears. In Sweden, Norway and Denmark, state supervision of the profession works alongside no-fault payments. In Poland, apart from the criminal court, only the self-government assesses the doctor as a person.

  2. 02.

    A payment triggers no assessment. The Fund does not indicate what or who failed, and accepting the payment closes the civil lawsuit in which that could be established.

  3. 03.

    The part that justifies no-fault is missing. Removing criminality is meant to encourage the reporting of errors. The act that was passed contains no duty to report, no protection for the reporter and no national register of events.

  4. 04.

    The effects cannot be measured. Asked by deputies how many medical-error cases end in a final conviction, the Ministry of Justice replied in 2025 that the courts’ statistical forms do not allow such information to be separated out.

Arguments in favour

Criminal liability for an error is already rare today, and proceedings are long. In 2017, prosecutors’ offices conducted 5,678 proceedings concerning medical errors. They closed 2,002 with a decision on the merits: 139 with an indictment, 2 with a motion for voluntary submission to a penalty, 1,613 by discontinuation and 248 by refusing to open proceedings. Discontinuations and refusals made up 93% of decisions on the merits.24 The National Prosecutor’s Office has not published newer data in this form.

The medical self-government concludes from this that criminal proceedings burden many doctors but rarely end in a judgment, and that fear of them discourages the disclosure of errors. A Swedish legal analysis reaches a similar assessment: punishing a mistake does little to prevent the next ones, and the risk of prosecution lowers the willingness to report events.7 The self-government’s demand also keeps a gross failure to exercise caution punishable.

We found no study showing that payments without deciding on fault worsen patient safety.

Notes 24laws, data and statements we relied on
  1. Löf (the Swedish regions’ mutual insurance company), Skadestatistik 2025 — Hela Sverige (in Swedish, PDF), 13 March 2026: the compensation rule, 22,800 reports, payment in just over 40% of cases decided, just under 740 million kronor. ↩

  2. Patienterstatningen, Årstal 2024 — Behandlingsskader, hele landet (in Danish, PDF), 2025: 13,327 reports, 12,683 decisions on entitlement, 22.3% recognised, 838.53 million kroner; description of the “specialistreglen” and “rimelighedsreglen” rules. ↩

  3. Lov om erstatning ved pasientskader mv. (pasientskadeloven) (in Norwegian), act of 15 June 2001 no. 53, section 2. ↩

  4. Norsk pasientskadeerstatning, Årsrapport 2025 (in Norwegian, PDF): 8,382 applications, 24% upheld (30% in 2020), 1,063 million kroner paid out, 225 days to a decision. ↩

  5. Andrew A., A no-fault approach to medical error: a New Zealand perspective, Journal of Hospital Management and Health Policy, 2025. ↩

  6. Cour des comptes, L’indemnisation amiable des victimes d’accidents médicaux (in French, PDF), annual report 2017, vol. 1. ↩

  7. Wahlberg L., Skäligt straffansvar för misstag inom medicin (in Swedish, PDF), Nordisk socialrättslig tidskrift no. 19–20, 2019. ↩ ↩2

  8. Gross negligence manslaughter in healthcare. The report of a rapid policy review (PDF), review led by Prof. Sir Norman Williams for the UK government, June 2018, para. 4.5. ↩

  9. Sundhedsvæsenets Disciplinærnævn, Årsberetning 2024 (in Danish, PDF). On Sweden and Norway: sources in the analysis “The harshest penalty that is almost never imposed”. ↩

  10. Health and Disability Commissioner, Annual Report 2024/25 (PDF). ↩

  11. Supreme Audit Office (NIK), audit report on out-of-court pursuit of claims by patients (in Polish, PDF), audit P/18/057, 2018. ↩

  12. Patient Ombudsman, report for 2024, Sejm paper no. 1733 (in Polish, PDF). ↩

  13. Government bill on quality in healthcare and patient safety, Sejm paper no. 2898 of 21 December 2022 (in Polish, PDF): Article 21 (prohibition of reprisals), Article 62 (extraordinary mitigation of the penalty and waiving its imposition). ↩

  14. Sejm, course of the legislative process, paper no. 2898 (in Polish): passed on 9 March 2023, Senate resolution rejecting the act of 30 March 2023, Sejm vote of 14 April 2023. ↩

  15. Act of 16 June 2023 on quality in healthcare and patient safety, Dz.U. 2023 item 1692 (in Polish, PDF). ↩

  16. Act of 16 June 2023 amending the Act on patient rights and the Patient Ombudsman and certain other acts, Dz.U. 2023 item 1675 (in Polish, PDF): definition of a medical event, chapter 13b — Article 67q (scope), Article 67s (amounts and indexation), Article 67x(4) (composition of the team), Article 67zc(2) (waiver of claims), Article 67zd(3) (analysis of causes in the hospital). ↩ ↩2

  17. Patient Ombudsman, report for 2025, Sejm paper no. 3042 (in Polish, PDF), chapter on the Medical Events Compensation Fund. ↩

  18. Position no. 1 of the Presidium of the Supreme Medical Council and the Presidium of the Supreme Council of Nurses and Midwives of 14 February 2024 (in Polish, PDF), Supreme Medical Chamber. ↩

  19. Prawo.pl, article on the no-fault clause for doctors: for and against (in Polish), 9 December 2024. ↩

  20. Act of 28 October 2020 amending certain acts in connection with counteracting crisis situations related to COVID-19, Dz.U. 2020 item 2112 (in Polish, PDF), Article 24. ↩

  21. Minister of Health, order of 2 June 2025, Official Journal of the Minister of Health 2025 item 34 (in Polish, PDF), and amending order of 2 July 2025, item 45 (in Polish, PDF). ↩

  22. Supreme Medical Chamber, figures on medical courts (in Polish): annual reports of the regional medical courts and the Supreme Medical Court; totals — own compilation described in the analysis “The harshest penalty that is almost never imposed”. ↩

  23. Ministry of Justice, reply of 12 June 2025 to interpellation no. 9798 (in Polish, PDF) and statistical tables (in Polish, PDF): records of cases for damages for harm caused by the health service in 2023–2024; totals for district and regional courts at first instance — own calculation. ↩ ↩2

  24. National Prosecutor’s Office, press release on proceedings concerning medical errors (in Polish), 5 April 2018; share of discontinuations and refusals — own calculation. ↩

How this text was made. The sources are public documents, data and legal acts — each linked in the notes. AI tools help process them: organise, calculate and edit the text. The editors decide on the arguments and approve every publication.

Spotted an error? We publish corrections in a register, with the date and a description of each change. We describe mechanisms, not individuals.

Report a correction

Euro amounts are approximate, converted at the National Bank of Poland mid rate of 20 November 2026 (table 226/A/NBP/2026): 1 EUR = 4.4559 PLN.

Editorial position

Public amounts, protected names.

We call on the state to publish, every quarter, the total pay of each person working in facilities with a National Health Fund (NFZ) contract — summed across all their workplaces, under a permanent identifier instead of a name.

Popular